The Struggles of Rebuilding the Detroit Tigers in MLB The Show 25 Franchise Mode
Posted by sunshine
from the Agriculture category at
07 Mar 2025 02:51:48 am.
Share this page: 
1. High Payroll and Long-Term Contracts
One of the Tigers’ most pressing issues is their inflated payroll. Several veterans, such as Miguel Cabrera, have massive contracts that weigh heavily on the budget and limit financial flexibility. While Cabrera has been a great player for the Tigers, his contract is a significant obstacle to rebuilding as it restricts the team’s ability to sign impactful free agents or make major trades.
Strategy: The key here is to evaluate your roster and begin making difficult decisions about which veterans to trade or release. Moving high-priced veterans like Cabrera (if possible) for younger, cost-controlled players will provide the financial breathing room you need to make impactful signings or trades in the future. Similarly, avoid giving long-term contracts to aging players and focus on adding affordable talent.
2. Aging Roster and Declining Performance
The Tigers' roster features a number of aging players whose skills are beginning to decline, which poses another challenge in the rebuild. Players like Cabrera, Jonathan Schoop, and Javier Báez are all good but have seen their best years fade, making them less valuable on the trade market.
Strategy: You’ll need to be proactive in moving these players before their value diminishes further. Many of the Tigers' veterans can be traded to teams that are contenders and in need of experienced players, thus opening up spots for younger, more promising talent. While this strategy may take some time, it’s crucial to clear room for fresh faces and potential stars.
3. Weak Farm System
Although the Tigers have made strides in developing talent in recent years, their farm system in MLB The Show 25 is still in need of significant improvement. While top prospects like Spencer Torkelson and Riley Greene offer hope for the future, there’s a lack of depth in the minors, especially in pitching. This lack of talent at the lower levels makes it difficult to build a competitive team without relying heavily on trades.
Strategy: The key to success in this rebuild is maximizing your draft picks and focusing on scouting. Make sure to prioritize drafting young, high-upside players who can become key contributors within a few seasons. Focus particularly on building up your pitching depth, as a strong rotation is essential for long-term success. Additionally, look for low-cost prospects through trades, targeting teams with deep systems or players who are underperforming but still have potential.
4. Lack of Top-Tier Prospects
While the Tigers do have some exciting prospects, they don’t have enough high-caliber talent in the pipeline to immediately impact the big-league roster. The lack of top-tier prospects, especially pitchers, makes it harder to quickly develop a competitive team from within.
Strategy: A good way to accelerate the rebuild is to prioritize developing the players you already have in your farm system. Assign your best scouting resources to work on identifying the next wave of potential stars, especially focusing on pitchers who can make an impact within the next few seasons. Consider making some riskier trades for high-ceiling prospects, even if they come with longer development timelines.
5. Limited Competitive Window
The Tigers, as of MLB The Show 25, are not a team ready to contend immediately. They’re in a transitional phase, and it could take several seasons before the roster is strong enough to make a playoff push. This prolonged timeline can be frustrating for franchise mode players eager to see immediate results.
Strategy: Instead of aiming for a quick fix, take a patient approach to rebuilding. Build through the draft, prioritize developing young talent, and make small, strategic moves that improve the team’s future outlook. Patience will be key as you wait for your younger players to develop into stars and for the Tigers to become a true contender again.
Conclusion: Rebuilding the Detroit Tigers in MLB The Show 25 is a challenge that requires patience, smart financial management, and effective player development. By focusing on clearing out aging contracts, building up your farm system, and targeting young talent, you can eventually bring the Tigers back to contention. Though it won’t happen overnight, with the right strategy, the Tigers can once again become a powerhouse in MLB.
Tags: MLB The Show 25
0 Comments